Nov 24, 2023
The boogeyman was real...Or was he?
This week, inspired by a listener, we're taking a good hard look at Staten Island. And it's not just Cropsey, there's the abandoned monastery, Kreischer Mansion, and even more that can't possibly fit.
We'll be back.
For full sources and links, visit
Nov 17, 2023
"I was proud of myself...for trying to understand you."
This week, Krissy has a cold, so we're doing something unusual!
WAY BACK in 2017, on a DIFFERENT podcast, we had a conversation with our mother Kathleen after she watched SCREAM for the first time.
The show is about so many other things too, but lets just revel in...
Nov 10, 2023
This episode is a punishment for Kristen.
Or…it was SUPPOSED to be.
Instead, we get a completely ENGROSSING introduction to a monster from a bygone era.
Why is The Phantom of the Opera SO compelling and creepy?!
For full sources and links, visit http://www.gttupod.com/home/gttu313
Listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or...
Nov 3, 2023
The myth is real. Blair Witch 2 is a perfect movie.
OR IS IT!?
For the FIRST TIME EVER, someone is going to take a CRITICAL look at Book of Shadows.
You'll be amazed at how many rabbit holes there are, and how deep they go.
It's honestly unbelievable.
Justice for Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2
OH, and this episode has...